Following are all the supernatural like words, in the list below.
OTHERWORLDLY
100% like supernatural
PRETERNATURAL
100% like supernatural
SPIRITUAL
100% like supernatural
APPARITIONAL
100% like supernatural
MIRACULOUS
100% like supernatural
PHANTASMAL
99.99% like supernatural
SPECTRAL
99.99% like supernatural
GHOSTLIKE
99.99% like supernatural
GHOSTLY
99.99% like supernatural
TRANSCENDENTAL
99.99% like supernatural
MAGICAL
99.99% like supernatural
TRANSMUNDANE
99.99% like supernatural
MAGIC
99.99% like supernatural
SORCEROUS
99.99% like supernatural
METAPHYSICAL
99.99% like supernatural
WIZARD
99.98% like supernatural
WIZARDLY
99.98% like supernatural
TALISMANIC
99.98% like supernatural
NECROMANTIC
99.97% like supernatural
WITCHLIKE
99.95% like supernatural
WITCHING
99.93% like supernatural
MARVELOUS
99.93% like supernatural
CHARMING
99.92% like supernatural
ELFIN
99.92% like supernatural
WEIRD
99.88% like supernatural
OCCULT
99.87% like supernatural
UNCANNY
99.86% like supernatural
ELDRITCH
99.86% like supernatural
FEY
99.76% like supernatural
UNEARTHLY
99.75% like supernatural
NONNATURAL
99.7% like supernatural
UNNATURAL
74.72% like supernatural
PARANORMAL
50.05% like supernatural
SUPERNATURALISM
50.05% like supernatural
SUPERNATURALISTIC
50.05% like supernatural
MYSTICAL
50.05% like supernatural
SUPRANATURAL
50.05% like supernatural
SUPERNATURE
50.05% like supernatural
SUPERNATURALIST
50.05% like supernatural
SPIRITISTIC
50.05% like supernatural
DEMONIC
50.05% like supernatural
PARAPSYCHOLOGICAL
50.05% like supernatural
SPIRITUALISTIC
50.05% like supernatural
THAUMATURGICAL
50.05% like supernatural
NUMINOUS
50.05% like supernatural
MYSTIC
50.05% like supernatural
EXORCISTIC
50.05% like supernatural
PARAPSYCHIC
50.05% like supernatural
SUPERSENSORY
50.05% like supernatural
MYSTICISM
50.05% like supernatural
DEMONOLOGICAL
50.05% like supernatural
DIVINE
50.05% like supernatural
MIRACLES
50.05% like supernatural
THAUMATURGIC
50.05% like supernatural
PSYCHOKINETIC
50.05% like supernatural
DAIMONIC
50.05% like supernatural
SUPERHUMAN
50.05% like supernatural
DEIFIC
50.05% like supernatural
REVELATIONAL
50.05% like supernatural
NATURALISM
50.05% like supernatural
PARANORMALLY
50.05% like supernatural
THEISTIC
50.05% like supernatural
EXTRASENSORY
50.05% like supernatural
SUPRAHUMAN
50.05% like supernatural
SUPERSTITION
50.05% like supernatural
MYTHOLOGICAL
50.05% like supernatural
LOVECRAFTIAN
50.05% like supernatural
UNEXPLAINABLE
50.05% like supernatural
SUPERSTITIOUSNESS
50.05% like supernatural
SUPERNATURALISTS
50.05% like supernatural
DEMONISM
50.05% like supernatural
PSYCHIC
50.05% like supernatural
SPIRITUALISM
50.05% like supernatural
WITCHCRAFT
50.05% like supernatural
DEMON
50.05% like supernatural
DEMONICAL
50.05% like supernatural
SATANICAL
50.05% like supernatural
POLTERGEIST
50.05% like supernatural
NATURAL
50.05% like supernatural
NATURALISTIC
50.05% like supernatural
SPOOKY
50.05% like supernatural
OTHERWORLDLINESS
50.05% like supernatural
FANTASTICAL
50.05% like supernatural
MYSTERIOUS
50.05% like supernatural
SUPERPHYSICAL
50.05% like supernatural
COSMIC
50.05% like supernatural
VAMPIRIC
50.05% like supernatural
RELIGIOUS
50.05% like supernatural
EXTRATERRESTRIAL
50.05% like supernatural
MYSTERY
50.05% like supernatural
PSYCHICAL
50.05% like supernatural
MAGICK
50.05% like supernatural
GHOSTLINESS
50.05% like supernatural
SORCERY
50.05% like supernatural
HAUNTINGS
50.05% like supernatural
VAMPIRE
50.05% like supernatural
SUPERSCIENCE
50.05% like supernatural
LUCIFERIC
50.05% like supernatural
PRAETERNATURAL
50.05% like supernatural
OTHERWORLD
50.05% like supernatural